Javert: Now Prisoner
24601, your time is up and your parole's begun. You know what that means?
Jean Valjean: Yes, it means I'm free.
Javert: No.
[hands him a yellow paper]
Javert: Follow to the letter your itinerary, this badge of shame
you wear until you die. It warns that you're a dangerous man/
Jean Valjean: I stole a loaf of bread. My sisters child was close to
death, and we were starving...
Javert: And you will starve again unless you learn the meaning of
the law!
Jean Valjean: I've learnt the meaning of those nineteen years; a slave of
the law.
Javert: Five years for what you did. The rest because you tried to
run, yes 24601...
Jean Valjean: My name is Jean Valjean!
Javert: And I'm Javert! Do not forget my name. Do not forget me,
24601.
|
Director: Tom Hooper (2012) |
The first trailer I saw of Tom Hooper’s Les
Miserables was before a 70mm screening of P.T Andersons The Master. At the time
the ambition of the trailer was impressive, yet in retrospect this positive
opinion was undoubtedly because of my excitement for Andersons impending film. The Les Mis trailer rubbed off on me though,
and the idea of the cast singing ‘live’ while they perform as opposed to a pre
recorded track was certainly intriguing, enough to warrant the price of
admission for a genre I despise. While there’s no denying Les Miserables
possesses good performances, great songs and a heartbreaking narrative, the
entire film is marred by some sloppy work from behind the camera.
Based on a play that’s adapted from a book,
we follow criminal Jean Valjean (Hugh Jackman), a man who’s spent 19 years in
prison for stealing a loaf of bread. His captor is the ruthless Inspector
Javert (Russell Crowe)a man who will hound him for the rest of his life. After
being freed Vajean breaks parole, becomes a factory owner and helps prostitute
Fantine (Anne Hathaway) by saving her daughter Cosette (the wonderfully
talented Isabelle Allen) from 2 cruel foster parents (Helena Bonham Carter and
Sacha Baron Cohen). As the years pass the student rebellion gains momentum in
France and the charismatic Marius (Eddie Redmayne) leads the fight, all while
becoming entangled in a love triangle with Cosette (Amanda Seyfried) and
Eponine (Samantha Barks). This conflict will change all their lives in the most
drastic of ways.
Operatic in tone, Les Mis has next to no
dialogue, but instead portrays its entire story through song. Many are fantastic,
both enjoyable to listen to and exemplary at developing the characters and
story. Yet some are borderline harrowing, no thanks to some poor singing and
acting. In fact, despite the star studded cast, very few actually live up to
their high billing. Crowe performs a double act of looking bored and singing
like he’s been punched in the throat, Seyfried’s voice is too shrill and Bonham
Carter and Baron Cohen trash every scene in that they appear. Their scene
singing “Master of the House” could be used as a form of torture to the sane
and tasteful.
Yet despite lacklustre performances from a
large chunk of the cast, Hugh Jackman steps up and saves the day. He is a tour
de force here, the spearhead that tears through the film in a brilliant,
admirable fashion, dominating every scene and every song. His inspired acting
holds the film together at the seams, making up for the poor singing from Crowe
and Seyfried and the poor performances from Bonham Carter and Baron Cohen.
Jackman has sacrificed much to appear in his beloved stage musicals and
performances making Les Mis is the perfect role for him, a combination of his 2
professions an apt demonstration of his underrated talents. You’ll never look
at Jean Valjean or Wolverine the same way again.
Complimenting Jackman’s stunning
performance is the riveting Miss Hathaway, bringing so much to a character whose
screentime is all too brief. Her Fantine is wracked with worry and despair, all
of which Hathaway emotes to a brilliant level of precision. While she doesn’t
put a foot or a note wrong, she’ll almost exclusively be remembered for her
rendition of “I Dreamed a Dream”, gloriously executed in a single unbroken
take. While such a moment of resonance happens little too early in the film, it
doesn’t detract from what will most likely be a winning performance come Oscar
night.
What isn’t up to the standard of Jackman
and Hathaway’s commitment to their roles is the directing of Tom Hooper. He has
a stern insistence on shooting the majority of the film in constraining and
stifling close ups, focusing solely on characters faces. While there is truth
in his belief that emotion is centred in the face, this is taking matters to
the extreme. Take the opening number “Look Down” for example. Valjean and a
myriad of other prisoners are pulling a ship into a massive dock as they sing
of their hardships. Such a song and event caters to the sense of scale that's
needed to do the narrative justice, yet instead we’re served facial shots of
Valjean and some other no name prisoners. It’s a maddening decision,
singlehandedly destroying some very important scenes as the camera jerks
around, barely keeping in focus. Even Hathaway’s film stealing solo is
tarnished by Hooper’s poor judgement; the depth of focus is so high her
powerhouse performance often becomes blurred. When you’re directing a committed
actor in such a spirited scene, the decision to shoot in such a way is
bewildering.
The technical failings don’t end here, as
Hooper is just as sloppy with his editing. While not as detrimental as the dire
cinematography, it gives the film a horribly rough finish, like an amateur had
taken the reigns for the first time on a high school project. It’s painful to
see Hooper act so sloppy, especially considering the phenomenal costume and set
design from (Eve Stewart). 19th century France is a grim and
disgusting location, expertly captured through the filthy streets and rundown
buildings. The costume design follows similar suite, impeccably designed to fit
the era and the character who dons them. When taking into consideration how
hard many people worked on these aspects for them to be ruined by some awful
direction, it starts to make The Kings Speech seem like a fluke.
By the time its painfully long running time
has reached the credits, Les Miserables will have shocked, confused, elevated
and disappointed practically every member of the audience. Beyond the abysmal
camerawork and direction there gleams a strong musical lead by some equally as
strong actors. In the hands of a more competent director this could have been a
masterpiece. Instead we get a mess, albeit a passionate one.