Sam: Hey, I recognize you.
Andrew Largeman: Oh, did you go to
Columbia High?
Sam: No, not from high school, from
TV. Didn't you play the retarded quarterback?
Andrew Largeman: Yeah.
Sam: Are you really retarded?
Andrew Largeman: No.
Sam: Ooh, great job man! I really
thought you were retarded. I mean, you're better than that Corky kid and he's
actually retarded. If there was a retarded Oscar you would win, hands down,
kick his ass!
Director: Zach Braff (2004) |
The only reason I decided to watch
acclaimed indie film Garden State was for a very ignorant and almost childish
reason. It’s the reason why teen girls watch Cronenberg’s Cosmopolis and young
women feel the need to watch 2011’s critically revered Drive. The answer?
Because the film stars an actor who I enjoy watching. That and Scrubs is a
fantastic piece of television. That's right, I watched Garden State solely on
the basis of writer/director/star Zach Braff, and this choice was a
surprisingly sound one, as Braff’s directorial debut is terrific little film.
The film follows Andrew ‘Large’ Largeman, a
little big actor who resides in LA. His career highlight was playing a retarded
quarterback in a TV film, but since then the acting well has turned barren.
Upon receiving the news of his mother’s death, Large returns home to New Jersey
for the first time in 9 years for the funeral that awkwardly collides him with
his estranged father (Ian Holm). Soon after catching up with his friends from
this previous life he bumps into Sam (Natalie Portman), an incredibly eccentric
20 something who he instantly has a connection to. In the remaining days of his
visit to Jersey he attempts to find himself and understand his path forwards in
life.
The remarkable themes of self discovery and
progress are at the heart of Garden State, and Braff's script tackles such bold
subject matter in a remarkably successful way. In different hands the film could’ve
veered off into the direction of monologues and nature shots, but the focus is
very much on the emotions of the characters. Large feels very isolated in his
life, perpetually on medication and unaware of his next move. One hilarious
scene sees his new handmade shirt match the wallpaper; a not so subtle metaphor
for being lost. Make no mistake, Braff’s direction isn’t particularly subtle,
but his choices certainly ring true without devolving into total
pretentiousness.
What’s certainly odd to see is Braff in a
role that isn’t the recognizable JD from Scrubs. The childish quirks of his
medically adept alter ego are missing here, instead Large is filled with a
somewhat emptiness. His voice is quiet and movements are reserved, never
wanting to be the centre of attention, even when people bring up his successful
ventures as an actor. Juxtaposing Large is the oddball attitude of Portman’s
Sam, the catalyst in Large’s life that brings him out of his self imposed
isolation. Portman certainly pulls it off here by bringing Sam to life and
making her simultaneously quirky and incredibly cringe worthy.
In interviews Braff has stated that Garden
State is a film about 20 something’s who haven’t planned out their lives past
the age of 21. This is employed in full force for the majority of scenes, from
the unemployed millionaire friend (“I've never been so bored in all my whole life”)
to gravedigger Mark (“I'm only 26. I'm not in any rush”). It
certainly allows the film to appeal to the aimless crowd of late teenagers and
college graduates, even if Braff’s script becomes incredibly melodramatic in
some of the more emotionally intense scenes.
For all its themes of existence and finding
ones path in life that takes up the majority of the film, it’s a complete shame
that the film’s final third (if it can be called that) is utterly lacking in a
multitude of departments. After some strong scenes of Large and Sam bonding,
the film goes quite literally on a detour leading the cute couple and Mark to
an abandoned quarry. Not only is the journey out of place and a little dull,
the film abandons its strongest thematic beats in favour of silly moments of
cliché. The climax is a kicker, the films thoughtful groundwork is undone by a
hideously generic RomCom ending. If it wasn’t for the quality tarnishing final
act, Garden State would be a slice of indie heaven. Instead it’s merely a good
film that never truly reaches its full potential.